So here’s where I get to spit on an icon by proxy. As those who know me know, I am not what one would call a churchgoing man. However, I happen to agree with this article by Mark Shea who tears apart “Imagine” by John Lennon:
Everything the song advocates and hopes for as a supreme good was the fountainhead of all the horrors of the 20th century. Imagine there’s no countries? Hitler dreamt of a world without borders. Imagine there’s no heaven? No religion too? Stalin and Mao sought to free us from religion and the burden of hoping for something more than this life. Imagine no possessions? Communism was all about freeing us from possessions (though multi-zillionaire Lennon seems to have honored this dream more in the breach than the observance). Imagine all the people living for today? You got it! A culture of brain-dead MTV-educated “fornicate-today-and-abort-tomorrow” zombies has accomplished the mission.
Like Shea, I also pay attention to lyrics and the pretty music that Lennon created does not cover up the fact that the song is, at best, vapid. I don’t say that John Lennon was a dreamer. I am not that kind. Lennon was a utopian fantasist, and I think that there is no bigger philosophical danger than belief in the perfectability of humanity. In my case this extends to religion as well, as when a religious group thinks that it can speed up some sort of prophecy if humans take matters into their own hands (I’m not pointing fingers, for once.)
I think the Beatles were great as a boy band, but John Lennon really lost it when he did too many drugs and became some sort of didactic stoner-prophet. The fact that he could successfully convert people into some sort of weird cult of “living for today” without paying heed to tomorrow disturbs me.
Thanks to Dawn Eden.
September 30, 2006
Categories: Music, Popular Culture . . Author: philbrick . Comments: Leave a comment